Skip to content
Carbon-neutral shipping with Shopify Planet
Carbon-neutral shipping on all orders
9578kg
shipping emissions removed
That's like...
24519
miles driven by an average gasoline-powered car
🎉 BIG SAVINGS ALERT! 🎉 Get $40 OFF on orders over $1000! 🛒 Use code BIGORDERCHEER at checkout. Hurry, offer ends soon!
🎉 BIG SAVINGS ALERT! 🎉 Get $40 OFF on orders over $1000! 🛒 Use code BIGORDERCHEER at checkout. Hurry, offer ends soon!

Assorted Premium Nut Butters

  • Original price $85.08 - Original price $85.08
    Original price $85.08
    $91.04
    $91.04 - $91.04
    Current price $91.04

    Justin's Peanut Butter with Honey (Pack of 12 - 16 oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Satisfy your sweet and nutty cravings with Justin's Peanut Butter with Honey, a pack of 12 generously-sized 16 oz. jars. This irresistible spread b...

    View full details
    Original price $85.08 - Original price $85.08
    Original price $85.08
    $91.04
    $91.04 - $91.04
    Current price $91.04
  • Original price $51.12 - Original price $51.12
    Original price $51.12
    $59.06
    $59.06 - $59.06
    Current price $59.06

    KIND Bar Granola Bars - Peanut Butter & Chocolate - 5/1.2 Oz - Case of 8

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the Sweetness of KIND Granola Peanut Butter & Chocolate Bars Crave-Worthy Blend of Peanut Butter and Chocolate Satisfy...

    View full details
    Original price $51.12 - Original price $51.12
    Original price $51.12
    $59.06
    $59.06 - $59.06
    Current price $59.06
  • Original price $120.90
    Original price $120.90 - Original price $120.90
    Original price $120.90
    Current price $116.83
    $116.83 - $116.83
    Current price $116.83

    Justin's Premium Peanut Butter Cups Easter Bag - 7.2 Oz, Pack of 10

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Sweeten Up Your Easter with Justin's Premium Peanut Butter Cups Key Features and Benefits: Easter-Themed Bag: Festive packaging perfect for East...

    View full details
    Original price $120.90
    Original price $120.90 - Original price $120.90
    Original price $120.90
    Current price $116.83
    $116.83 - $116.83
    Current price $116.83
    Sold out
  • Original price $103.32
    Original price $103.32 - Original price $103.32
    Original price $103.32
    Current price $82.29
    $82.29 - $82.29
    Current price $82.29

    Larabar - Bar Peanut Butter Cookie - Case Of 8-6/1.7 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Larabar - bar peanut butter cookie - case of 8-6/1.7 ozcountry of origin : usa, minnesotais dairy free : yesis gluten free : yesis gmo free : yesi...

    View full details
    Original price $103.32
    Original price $103.32 - Original price $103.32
    Original price $103.32
    Current price $82.29
    $82.29 - $82.29
    Current price $82.29
    Sold out
  • Original price $60.54 - Original price $60.54
    Original price $60.54
    $67.30
    $67.30 - $67.30
    Current price $67.30

    Michele's Granola Almond Butter Six-Pack, 12 Oz. Each

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Start Your Day with Crunchy Goodness: Michele's Granola Almond Butter: A Six-Pack of Flavorful Nutrition Indulge in a wholesome breakfast or aftern...

    View full details
    Original price $60.54 - Original price $60.54
    Original price $60.54
    $67.30
    $67.30 - $67.30
    Current price $67.30
    Sold out
  • Original price $138.94
    Original price $138.94 - Original price $138.94
    Original price $138.94
    Current price $111.67
    $111.67 - $111.67
    Current price $111.67

    Larabar - Bar Peanut Butter Cookie - Case Of 6-12/1.7 Z

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Larabar - bar peanut butter cookie - case of 6-12/1.7 zcountry of origin : usa, minnesotais dairy free : yesis gluten free : yesis gmo free : yesi...

    View full details
    Original price $138.94
    Original price $138.94 - Original price $138.94
    Original price $138.94
    Current price $111.67
    $111.67 - $111.67
    Current price $111.67
    Sold out
  • Original price $64.72 - Original price $64.72
    Original price $64.72
    $71.24
    $71.24 - $71.24
    Current price $71.24

    Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread: Peanut Butter Alternative (Pack of 8 x 13.4 Oz)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Flavorful Cookie Butter: A Savory Twist on Peanut Butter Premium Cookie Butter at Your Fingertips: Savor the delectable combination...

    View full details
    Original price $64.72 - Original price $64.72
    Original price $64.72
    $71.24
    $71.24 - $71.24
    Current price $71.24
  • Original price $47.99 - Original price $47.99
    Original price $47.99
    $51.23
    $51.23 - $51.23
    Current price $51.23

    KOS Plant Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter - 20.56 Oz.

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Nutrient-Rich, Tummy-Pleasing, Plant-Based Protein About The Product: Indulge in the delectable union of chocolate and peanut butter with KOS Pla...

    View full details
    Original price $47.99 - Original price $47.99
    Original price $47.99
    $51.23
    $51.23 - $51.23
    Current price $51.23
    Sold out
  • Original price $39.48 - Original price $39.48
    Original price $39.48
    $49.00
    $49.00 - $49.00
    Current price $49.00

    Lenny & Larry's Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, 4 Oz (Case of 12)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    The Lenny & Larry's Complete Cookie: A Protein and Fiber Powerhouse Satisfy Your Cravings, Without the Guilt Indulge in a rich and chewy cook...

    View full details
    Original price $39.48 - Original price $39.48
    Original price $39.48
    $49.00
    $49.00 - $49.00
    Current price $49.00
  • Original price $41.68
    Original price $41.68 - Original price $41.68
    Original price $41.68
    Current price $32.93
    $32.93 - $32.93
    Current price $32.93

    Keto Krisp (Pack of 12) Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk - 1.59 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in a delicious guilt-free treat with Keto Krisp Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk bars! Made with premium ingredients like peanuts, chicory r...

    View full details
    Original price $41.68
    Original price $41.68 - Original price $41.68
    Original price $41.68
    Current price $32.93
    $32.93 - $32.93
    Current price $32.93
    Sold out
  • Original price $10.90 - Original price $10.90
    Original price $10.90
    $23.46
    $23.46 - $23.46
    Current price $23.46

    Justin's Squeeze Pack Peanut Butter Classic (1.15 Oz., Pack of 10)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Justin's Classic Peanut Butter Squeeze Packs - Healthy Snack 10 Pack (1.15 oz) Indulge in the Nutty Goodness of Justin's Classic Peanut Butter Squ...

    View full details
    Original price $10.90 - Original price $10.90
    Original price $10.90
    $23.46
    $23.46 - $23.46
    Current price $23.46
  • Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.00
    $50.00 - $50.00
    Current price $50.00

    Kate's Real Food Bar Grzly Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate 2.2 Oz Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Kate's Real Food BarGrzly Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate 2.2 Oz Case of 12Feed Your EnergyKeep your body energized with Kate's Real Food Bar Grzly Pe...

    View full details
    Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.00
    $50.00 - $50.00
    Current price $50.00
  • Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50 - Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50
    Current price $23.74
    $23.74 - $23.74
    Current price $23.74

    Kize Concepts - Energy Bar Raw Peanut Butter (Pack of 10 1.6oz)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Kize Concepts Peanut Butter Raw Energy Bar is the perfect snack for those looking for a healthy and natural food option. This 1.6 oz bar contains...

    View full details
    Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50 - Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50
    Current price $23.74
    $23.74 - $23.74
    Current price $23.74
    Sold out
  • Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $50.73
    $50.73 - $50.73
    Current price $50.73

    Lupii Almond Butter Chocolate Chip Bars (Pack of 12), 1.76 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Lupii Almond Butter Chocolate Chip Bar: Indulge in a Healthy TreatKey Features & Benefits: All-Natural Ingredients: Made with real almonds, ch...

    View full details
    Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $50.73
    $50.73 - $50.73
    Current price $50.73
    Sold out
  • Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $42.96
    $42.96 - $42.96
    Current price $42.96

    Lily's Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, 12 Pack - 1.25 oz each

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Lily's Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, 12 Pack Indulge in the delectable flavors of Lily's Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, masterfully craft...

    View full details
    Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $42.96
    $42.96 - $42.96
    Current price $42.96
  • Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28 - Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28
    Current price $54.77
    $54.77 - $54.77
    Current price $54.77

    Lily's Dark Chocolate 55% Cacao with Peanut Butter 2.8oz Bar (Pack of 12)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in Pure Decadence with Lily's Dark Chocolate and Creamy Peanut Butter Bars Lily's Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups: A Symphony of Sweet a...

    View full details
    Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28 - Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28
    Current price $54.77
    $54.77 - $54.77
    Current price $54.77
    Sold out
  • Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $43.03
    $43.03 - $43.03
    Current price $43.03

    Munk Pack Keto Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Unleash Your Keto Cravings with Munk Pack Keto Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate The Perfect Keto Snack, Minus the Guilt Indulge in the irresist...

    View full details
    Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $43.03
    $43.03 - $43.03
    Current price $43.03
  • Original price $63.12 - Original price $63.12
    Original price $63.12
    $68.87
    $68.87 - $68.87
    Current price $68.87

    Maxine's Heavenly Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Cookies, 8 Pack of 7.2 Oz. Packages

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Heavenly Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Bliss, One Bite at a Time Key Features and Benefits: Indulge in generously sized 7.2 Oz. packages...

    View full details
    Original price $63.12 - Original price $63.12
    Original price $63.12
    $68.87
    $68.87 - $68.87
    Current price $68.87
  • Original price $48.72 - Original price $48.72
    Original price $48.72
    $56.63
    $56.63 - $56.63
    Current price $56.63

    Kind - Simple Crunch Peanut Butter (Pack of 8-5/1.4 Oz)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    This pack of 8-5/1.4 Oz of Kind - Simple Crunch Peanut Butter is a delicious, crunchy, and nutritious snack perfect for any occasion. Crafted in ...

    View full details
    Original price $48.72 - Original price $48.72
    Original price $48.72
    $56.63
    $56.63 - $56.63
    Current price $56.63
    Sold out
  • Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $51.19
    $51.19 - $51.19
    Current price $51.19

    Lupii Bites Protein Peanut Butter with Cacao Nibs, 12-Pack of 1.76 Oz Each

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Lupii Bites Protein Peanut Butter with Cacao Nibs, 12-Pack of 1.76 Oz Each Unleash Your Cravings with Lupii Bites: The Ultimate Protein-Powered P...

    View full details
    Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $51.19
    $51.19 - $51.19
    Current price $51.19
    Sold out
  • Original price $87.34
    Original price $87.34 - Original price $87.34
    Original price $87.34
    Current price $69.90
    $69.90 - $69.90
    Current price $69.90

    Maranatha Almond Butter, No Sugar Crunchy, 12 Oz (Pack of 6)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Crunchy Almond Butter Goodness: Maranatha Almond Butter, Free from Sugar Maranatha Almond Butter, No Sugar Crunchy, 12 Oz (Pack of 6) Key Featur...

    View full details
    Original price $87.34
    Original price $87.34 - Original price $87.34
    Original price $87.34
    Current price $69.90
    $69.90 - $69.90
    Current price $69.90
    Sold out
  • Original price $64.72 - Original price $64.72
    Original price $64.72
    $71.24
    $71.24 - $71.24
    Current price $71.24

    Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread - Crunchy, Peanut Butter Alternative (8 Pack)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Crunchy Cookie Butter Spread | 8-Pack of 13-ounce Jars Cookie Butter Alternative to Peanut Butter Key Features & Benefits: Creamy, crunchy ...

    View full details
    Original price $64.72 - Original price $64.72
    Original price $64.72
    $71.24
    $71.24 - $71.24
    Current price $71.24
  • Original price $105.28
    Original price $105.28 - Original price $105.28
    Original price $105.28
    Current price $102.89
    $102.89 - $102.89
    Current price $102.89

    Lily's Sweets Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, 3.2 Oz - Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Feel the sweet and savory joy with Lily's Sweets Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate The Perfect Indulgence for Peanut Butter Lovers Crav...

    View full details
    Original price $105.28
    Original price $105.28 - Original price $105.28
    Original price $105.28
    Current price $102.89
    $102.89 - $102.89
    Current price $102.89
  • Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50 - Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50
    Current price $23.74
    $23.74 - $23.74
    Current price $23.74

    Kize Concepts - Energy Bar Raw Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip (Pack of 10 1.5oz)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    This Kize peanut butter chocolate chip raw energy bar provides 9 g. of protein and is made from only six delicious ingredients: premium peanut bu...

    View full details
    Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50 - Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50
    Current price $23.74
    $23.74 - $23.74
    Current price $23.74
    Sold out

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare