Skip to content
Carbon-neutral shipping with Shopify Planet
Carbon-neutral shipping on all orders
9578kg
shipping emissions removed
That's like...
24519
miles driven by an average gasoline-powered car
More info
🎉 BIG SAVINGS ALERT! 🎉 Get $40 OFF on orders over $1000! 🛒 Use code BIGORDERCHEER at checkout. Hurry, offer ends soon!
🎉 BIG SAVINGS ALERT! 🎉 Get $40 OFF on orders over $1000! 🛒 Use code BIGORDERCHEER at checkout. Hurry, offer ends soon!
Order Online Or Call (508) 941-8992
Your Cart
COCOA BUTTER COCOA POWDER TART SHELL VANILLA SPICES FRUIT CHILES NUTS SUGAR AND SWEETENERS GRAINS & SEEDS FLOURS KOSHER

Assorted Premium Nut Butters

  • $86.28 - $86.28
    $86.28
    $91.09
    $91.09 - $91.09
    $91.09

    Barbara's Bakery Puffins Peanut Butter Cereal (Pack of 12 - 11 Oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Barbara's Bakery Puffins Peanut Butter Cereal - A Wholesome and Delicious Breakfast Choice Nourish Your Mornings with Puffins Peanut Butter Cereal ...

    View full details
    $86.28 - $86.28
    $86.28
    $91.09
    $91.09 - $91.09
    $91.09
  • $23.40 - $23.40
    $23.40
    $34.24
    $34.24 - $34.24
    $34.24

    Bar Wndrlst Protein Puck Peanut Butter Cranberry - 1.34 oz, 12 Pack

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Power Up with Protein on the Go: Bar Wndrlst Protein Puck Peanut Butter Cranberry Indulge in a convenient and delectable snack that fuels your a...

    View full details
    $23.40 - $23.40
    $23.40
    $34.24
    $34.24 - $34.24
    $34.24
  • $41.34 - $41.34
    $41.34
    $50.80
    $50.80 - $50.80
    $50.80

    Back To Nature Peanut Butter Creme Cookies (6-Pack, 9.6 Oz. Each)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the Creamy Peanut Butter Delight of Back To Nature Cookies Satisfy your sweet tooth and nourish your body with the wholesome goodness ...

    View full details
    $41.34 - $41.34
    $41.34
    $50.80
    $50.80 - $50.80
    $50.80
  • Sold out
    $41.34 - $41.34
    $41.34
    $50.66
    $50.66 - $50.66
    $50.66

    Back to Nature Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Cookie (8 oz., 6-Pack)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Back to Nature Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Cookie Taste the Goodness of Real Ingredients! Savor the delectable combination of rich chocolate c...

    View full details
    $41.34 - $41.34
    $41.34
    $50.66
    $50.66 - $50.66
    $50.66
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $50.50
    $50.50 - $50.50
    $50.50
    $39.76
    $39.76 - $39.76
    $39.76

    Awake Chocolate Bites (Pack of 50) 0.58oz Peanut Butter Chocolate

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in Awake Chocolate Bites, a delicious combination of creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate in every bite. With a pack of 50 - .58 oz ...

    View full details
    $50.50
    $50.50 - $50.50
    $50.50
    $39.76
    $39.76 - $39.76
    $39.76
    Sold out
  • $10.49 - $10.49
    $10.49
    $24.91
    $24.91 - $24.91
    $24.91

    Atkins Endulge Peanut Butter Cups (Pack of 5)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    A Perfectly Balanced Blend of Chocolate and Creamy Peanut Butter Indulge in the irresistible treat of Atkins Endulge Peanut Butter Cups. These del...

    View full details
    $10.49 - $10.49
    $10.49
    $24.91
    $24.91 - $24.91
    $24.91
  • Sold out
    $11.69 - $11.69
    $11.69
    $26.01
    $26.01 - $26.01
    $26.01

    Atkins Day Break Bar Peanut Butter Fudge Crisp (Pack of 5 Bars)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    The Atkins Day Break Bar Peanut Butter Fudge Crisp is the perfect combination of flavor and nutrition. Packed with 10g of protein and only 2g of ...

    View full details
    $11.69 - $11.69
    $11.69
    $26.01
    $26.01 - $26.01
    $26.01
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $15.49 - $15.49
    $15.49
    $29.83
    $29.83 - $29.83
    $29.83

    Atkins Advantage Peanut Butter Granola Bars (5-Pack)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Healthy and Convenient Snacking with Atkins Advantage Peanut Butter Granola Bars Atkins Advantage Peanut Butter Granola Bars (5-Pack) Key Feature...

    View full details
    $15.49 - $15.49
    $15.49
    $29.83
    $29.83 - $29.83
    $29.83
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $15.49 - $15.49
    $15.49
    $29.83
    $29.83 - $29.83
    $29.83

    Atkins Advantage Bar Chocolate Peanut Butter - Pack of 5

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in Guilt-Free Snacking: Atkins Advantage Bar Chocolate Peanut Butter Enjoy the Perfect Balance of Chocolatey Goodness and Peanut Buttery D...

    View full details
    $15.49 - $15.49
    $15.49
    $29.83
    $29.83 - $29.83
    $29.83
    Sold out
  • $59.39 - $59.39
    $59.39
    $60.40
    $60.40 - $60.40
    $60.40

    Ascent Native Fuel Whey Chocolate Peanut Butter (2 Lb.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Ascent Native Fuel Whey Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Powder Key Features & Benefits: 25g of Native Whey Protein per serving All-Natural, N...

    View full details
    $59.39 - $59.39
    $59.39
    $60.40
    $60.40 - $60.40
    $60.40
  • Sold out
    $26.50
    $26.50 - $26.50
    $26.50
    $20.59
    $20.59 - $20.59
    $20.59

    Artisana Organic Raw Almond Butter Squeeze Packs (Pack of 10) - 1.06 Oz Each

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Artisana Organic Raw Almond Butter Squeeze Packs (Pack of 10) Artisana Organic Raw Almond Butter Squeeze Packs Nourishing Snack ...

    View full details
    $26.50
    $26.50 - $26.50
    $26.50
    $20.59
    $20.59 - $20.59
    $20.59
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $87.28
    $87.28 - $87.28
    $87.28
    $85.31
    $85.31 - $85.31
    $85.31

    Annie's Organic Chewy Granola Bars, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, 12-Pack, 5.34 Oz.

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Annie's Homegrown Organic Chewy Granola Bars are a delicious and nutritious snack made with wholesome ingredients. Each bar is packed with 18 gra...

    View full details
    $87.28
    $87.28 - $87.28
    $87.28
    $85.31
    $85.31 - $85.31
    $85.31
    Sold out
  • $31.49
    $31.49 - $31.49
    $31.49
    $28.69
    $28.69 - $28.69
    $28.69

    Andalou Naturals Retinol Cream Rejuvenating Peanut Butter, 1.7 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Reveal Youthful, Radiant Skin Andalou Naturals Retinol Cream Rejuvenating Peanut Butter Experience a transformative skincare journey with Andalou ...

    View full details
    $31.49
    $31.49 - $31.49
    $31.49
    $28.69
    $28.69 - $28.69
    $28.69
  • Sold out
    $15.29 - $15.29
    $15.29
    $17.27
    $17.27 - $17.27
    $17.27

    Andalou Naturals Retinol Crème Rejuvenating Peanut Butter - 1 oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Andalou Naturals Retinol Crème Rejuvenating Peanut Butter Experience visibly younger skin with Andalou Naturals Retinol Crème Rejuvenating Peanut...

    View full details
    $15.29 - $15.29
    $15.29
    $17.27
    $17.27 - $17.27
    $17.27
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $92.72 - $92.72
    $92.72
    $93.17
    $93.17 - $93.17
    $93.17

    Alter Eco Bombs Almond Butter, 3.8 oz - Pack of 8

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Alter Eco Bombs Almond Butter - Pack of 8 Organic and Nutritious: Crafted from 100% organic, USDA-certified almonds Rich in essential vitamins,...

    View full details
    $92.72 - $92.72
    $92.72
    $93.17
    $93.17 - $93.17
    $93.17
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $42.88 - $42.88
    $42.88
    $47.67
    $47.67 - $47.67
    $47.67

    Aloha Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip (Pack of 12) - 1.9 Oz.

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in a sweet and healthy snack with Aloha Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Protein Bar. This delicious bar is made with natural ingredients inc...

    View full details
    $42.88 - $42.88
    $42.88
    $47.67
    $47.67 - $47.67
    $47.67
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $55.08 - $55.08
    $55.08
    $61.66
    $61.66 - $61.66
    $61.66

    Almondina Original Almond Butter Biscuits (Pack of 12 - 4 Oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Almond Butter Biscuits Thrilling, Tasty Almond Butter Biscuits (Pack of 12) Key Features and Benefits: Indulge in the delightful crunch and s...

    View full details
    $55.08 - $55.08
    $55.08
    $61.66
    $61.66 - $61.66
    $61.66
    Sold out
  • $218.58
    $218.58 - $218.58
    $218.58
    $201.34
    $201.34 - $201.34
    $201.34

    Albanese Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups - 2.5 lb Bag (Case of 2)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Albanese Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups - At-A-Glance Delight in the classics with Albanese Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups! Th...

    View full details
    $218.58
    $218.58 - $218.58
    $218.58
    $201.34
    $201.34 - $201.34
    $201.34
  • ALMOND PASTE BUCKET
    $257.52 - $257.52
    $257.52
    $257.52 - $257.52
    $257.52

    ALMOND PASTE BUCKET

    AMERICAN ALMOND
    In stock

    Features: High-quality almond paste made from premium almonds Smooth and pliable texture that is easy to mold and shape Provides a rich and nutty ...

    View full details
    $257.52 - $257.52
    $257.52
    $257.52 - $257.52
    $257.52
  • almond butterALMOND BUTTERALMOND BUTTERSpecialty Food Source Features: Made from high-quality roasted almonds that are finely ground for a creamy and smooth texture Nutty and slightly sweet flavor, perfect for spreading on t
    $54.38 - $317.13
    $54.38 - $317.13
    $54.38 - $317.13
    $54.38

    ALMOND BUTTER

    AMERICAN ALMOND
    In stock

    Introducing the American Almond Brand Almond Butter in a convenient #10 can, offering culinary professionals a versatile and premium ingredient for...

    View full details
    $54.38 - $317.13
    $54.38 - $317.13
    $54.38 - $317.13
    $54.38

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare