Skip to content
Carbon-neutral shipping with Shopify Planet
Carbon-neutral shipping on all orders
9578kg
shipping emissions removed
That's like...
24519
miles driven by an average gasoline-powered car
More info
🎉 BIG SAVINGS ALERT! 🎉 Get $40 OFF on orders over $1000! 🛒 Use code BIGORDERCHEER at checkout. Hurry, offer ends soon!
🎉 BIG SAVINGS ALERT! 🎉 Get $40 OFF on orders over $1000! 🛒 Use code BIGORDERCHEER at checkout. Hurry, offer ends soon!
Order Online Or Call (508) 941-8992
Your Cart
COCOA BUTTER COCOA POWDER TART SHELL VANILLA SPICES FRUIT CHILES NUTS SUGAR AND SWEETENERS GRAINS & SEEDS FLOURS KOSHER

Assorted Premium Nut Butters

  • $33.48 - $33.48
    $33.48
    $43.14
    $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14

    Power Crunch Bar - Peanut Butter Fudge, Case of 12 - 1.4 oz Bars

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    A Delicious, Convenient Treat That'll Power You Through Your Day! Power Crunch Bar - Peanut Butter Fudge, Case of 12 - 1.4 oz Bars The Perfect Sn...

    View full details
    $33.48 - $33.48
    $33.48
    $43.14
    $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14
  • $20.94 - $20.94
    $20.94
    $24.61
    $24.61 - $24.61
    $24.61

    Puffworks - Puff Baby Peanut Butter (Pack of 6 - 6.5oz)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Make Snack Time Fun for Your Little Peanut! Puffworks Puff Baby Peanut Butter - 6.5oz, 6-Pack Introduce your little one to the delicious and whol...

    View full details
    $20.94 - $20.94
    $20.94
    $24.61
    $24.61 - $24.61
    $24.61
  • Sold out
    $93.34 - $93.34
    $93.34
    $93.95
    $93.95 - $93.95
    $93.95

    Once Again Almond Butter Classic No Stir Natural (Pack of 6 - 16 Oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Once Again Almond Butter Classic No Stir Natural is the perfect addition to your pantry. This product offers a creamy texture, free of hydrogenat...

    View full details
    $93.34 - $93.34
    $93.34
    $93.95
    $93.95 - $93.95
    $93.95
    Sold out
  • $40.50 - $40.50
    $40.50
    $50.10
    $50.10 - $50.10
    $50.10

    Newman's Own Organics Premium Peanut Butter Dog Treats (6-Pack)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge your furry companion in the irresistible flavor and goodness of Newman's Own Organics Premium Peanut Butter Dog Treats. Uniquely Crafted f...

    View full details
    $40.50 - $40.50
    $40.50
    $50.10
    $50.10 - $50.10
    $50.10
  • Sold out
    $63.54 - $63.54
    $63.54
    $72.50
    $72.50 - $72.50
    $72.50

    Once Again Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter 6-Pack, 16 Oz. Jars

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Once Again Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter 6-Pack 100% Natural, Stone Ground for a Rich Flavor Indulge in the wholesome goodness of Once Again Organ...

    View full details
    $63.54 - $63.54
    $63.54
    $72.50
    $72.50 - $72.50
    $72.50
    Sold out
  • $32.98 - $32.98
    $32.98
    $43.76
    $43.76 - $43.76
    $43.76

    PB2 Peanut Butter Powder - Original, 2-Pack (24 Oz Each)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Say goodbye to chunky peanut butter and hello to silky-smooth PB2® Original Peanut Butter Powder! Unlock the Power of Pure Peanuts PB2® Peanut Bu...

    View full details
    $32.98 - $32.98
    $32.98
    $43.76
    $43.76 - $43.76
    $43.76
  • $63.54 - $63.54
    $63.54
    $72.50
    $72.50 - $72.50
    $72.50

    Once Again Peanut Butter, Smooth, Salt-Free (Pack of 6 - 16 Oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Once Again Peanut Butter, Smooth, Salt-Free Creamy, Smooth Peanut Butter Made with Just Peanuts Key Features: Crafted from premium-quality pe...

    View full details
    $63.54 - $63.54
    $63.54
    $72.50
    $72.50 - $72.50
    $72.50
  • Sold out
    $45.54 - $45.54
    $45.54
    $54.70
    $54.70 - $54.70
    $54.70

    Newman's Own Organics Peanut Butter Creme Chocolate Cookies, 13 Oz Pack of 6

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Dive into the decadent indulgence of Newman's Own Organics Peanut Butter Creme Chocolate Cookies, where the crunch of wholesome grains harmonizes w...

    View full details
    $45.54 - $45.54
    $45.54
    $54.70
    $54.70 - $54.70
    $54.70
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $58.39 - $58.39
    $58.39
    $59.67
    $59.67 - $59.67
    $59.67

    Orgain - Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder - Peanut Butter - 2.03 Lb

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Orgain's Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder is perfect for athletes, fitness enthusiasts, and health-conscious individuals looking for a deliciou...

    View full details
    $58.39 - $58.39
    $58.39
    $59.67
    $59.67 - $59.67
    $59.67
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $75.48 - $75.48
    $75.48
    $78.83
    $78.83 - $78.83
    $78.83

    Ocho Candy Peanut Butter Mini Pouch, 3.5 Oz - Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Peanut Butter Bliss in a Mini Pouch: Ocho Candy Peanut Butter Indulge in the Creamy Goodness Smooth and rich peanut butter filling Satisfying b...

    View full details
    $75.48 - $75.48
    $75.48
    $78.83
    $78.83 - $78.83
    $78.83
    Sold out
  • $55.14 - $55.14
    $55.14
    $63.21
    $63.21 - $63.21
    $63.21

    Nuttzo Peanut Butter Smooth, 12 Oz Jars (Pack of 6)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    NuttZo Smooth Peanut Butter ia all about good things going around and around, whether it be the creamy peanut butter or the karma that comes from ...

    View full details
    $55.14 - $55.14
    $55.14
    $63.21
    $63.21 - $63.21
    $63.21
  • $45.48 - $45.48
    $45.48
    $56.06
    $56.06 - $56.06
    $56.06

    Pro Bar Organic Peanut Butter Bar, 12 - 3 oz. Packs

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Fuel Your Adventure with Probar Organic Peanut Butter Bar: Probar Organic Peanut Butter Bar - Natural Energy Source for Active Lifestyles Indulge...

    View full details
    $45.48 - $45.48
    $45.48
    $56.06
    $56.06 - $56.06
    $56.06
  • $52.72 - $52.72
    $52.72
    $59.37
    $59.37 - $59.37
    $59.37

    Puffworks Gluten-Free Original Peanut Butter (8-Pack, 3.5 oz)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Puffworks Gluten-Free Original Peanut Butter (8-Pack, 3.5 oz) Puffworks Gluten-Free Original Peanut Butter (8-Pack, 3.5 oz) Satisfy Your Cra...

    View full details
    $52.72 - $52.72
    $52.72
    $59.37
    $59.37 - $59.37
    $59.37
  • Sold out
    $52.72 - $52.72
    $52.72
    $59.37
    $59.37 - $59.37
    $59.37

    Puffworks Gluten Free Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Bites - 8 Pack, 3.5 Oz. Each, 0.9 Degrees Temperature

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Puffworks Gluten Free Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Bites Decadent Delight for the Discerning Palate Indulge in the tantalizing fusion of rich dar...

    View full details
    $52.72 - $52.72
    $52.72
    $59.37
    $59.37 - $59.37
    $59.37
    Sold out
  • $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14
    $53.27
    $53.27 - $53.27
    $53.27

    Peanut Butter & Co. Crunchy Peanut Butter (16 Oz., 6-Pack)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Peanut Butter & Co. Crunchy Peanut Butter (16 Oz., 6-Pack) Experience the irresistible taste and wholesome goodness of Peanut Butter & Co....

    View full details
    $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14
    $53.27
    $53.27 - $53.27
    $53.27
  • $71.34 - $71.34
    $71.34
    $76.66
    $76.66 - $76.66
    $76.66

    PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter (6 Pack, 16 Oz Each)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter (6 Pack, 16 Oz Each) | Peanut Butter Powerhouse PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter: The Ultimate Peanut Butter Alter...

    View full details
    $71.34 - $71.34
    $71.34
    $76.66
    $76.66 - $76.66
    $76.66
  • $33.48 - $33.48
    $33.48
    $43.14
    $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14

    Power Crunch Peanut Butter Cream Bar Value Pack (12 - 1.4 Oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the Irresistible Taste of Power Crunch Peanut Butter Cream Bar Value Pack! Savor the Perfect Blend of Protein and Flavor Power Crunch Pe...

    View full details
    $33.48 - $33.48
    $33.48
    $43.14
    $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14
  • $20.94 - $20.94
    $20.94
    $24.61
    $24.61 - $24.61
    $24.61

    Puffworks Puff Baby Almond Butter - 6.5 Oz Case

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Puffworks Puff Baby Almond Butter - 6.5 Oz Case Nourishing Spread for Growing Tots Essential Nutrients for Little Ones Rich in Protein: Suppor...

    View full details
    $20.94 - $20.94
    $20.94
    $24.61
    $24.61 - $24.61
    $24.61
  • Sold out
    $27.80
    $27.80 - $27.80
    $27.80
    $22.67
    $22.67 - $22.67
    $22.67

    Pro Bar Almond Butter P0p Nutritional Bar - Case Of 8 - 2.00 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Pro bar almond butter p0p nutritional bar is made with ingredients that include almonds, date paste, almond butter, sunflower seeds, cocoa butter, ...

    View full details
    $27.80
    $27.80 - $27.80
    $27.80
    $22.67
    $22.67 - $22.67
    $22.67
    Sold out
  • $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14
    $53.27
    $53.27 - $53.27
    $53.27

    Peanut Butter & Co. Dark Chocolate Dreamy Peanut Butter Spread (Pack of 6 -16 Oz.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the Dark Chocolate Dream from Peanut Butter & Co. A Decadent Treat for Chocolate Lovers and Peanut Butter Aficionados Savor the h...

    View full details
    $43.14 - $43.14
    $43.14
    $53.27
    $53.27 - $53.27
    $53.27
  • $89.34 - $89.34
    $89.34
    $94.06
    $94.06 - $94.06
    $94.06

    Once Again Organic Almond Butter Creamy 16 Oz. (Pack of 6)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Wholesome Goodness: Once Again Organic Creamy Almond Butter (6-Pack) Key Benefits: 100% Organic California Almonds: Sourced from ethical farms f...

    View full details
    $89.34 - $89.34
    $89.34
    $94.06
    $94.06 - $94.06
    $94.06
  • $47.94 - $47.94
    $47.94
    $59.66
    $59.66 - $59.66
    $59.66

    Once Again Crunchy Salted Peanut Butter, Pack of Six, 16 Oz. Jars

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Crunchy Salted Peanut Butter Indulge in the irresistible crunch and savory goodness of Once Again Crunchy Salted Peanut Butter. This wholesome spr...

    View full details
    $47.94 - $47.94
    $47.94
    $59.66
    $59.66 - $59.66
    $59.66
  • Sold out
    $41.79 - $41.79
    $41.79
    $50.09
    $50.09 - $50.09
    $50.09

    Primal Kitchen Collagen Fuel Peanut Butter - 14.3 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Fuel Your Body with Primal Kitchen Collagen Fuel Peanut Butter Key Features & Benefits: Provides 15g of protein per serving Contains 10g of c...

    View full details
    $41.79 - $41.79
    $41.79
    $50.09
    $50.09 - $50.09
    $50.09
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    $37.27
    $37.27 - $37.27
    $37.27
    $29.30
    $29.30 - $29.30
    $29.30

    Pirq - Protein Shake Vanilla Peanut Butter 4pk - Case Of 3-4/11 Fz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Super foods. Say hello to pirq. Deliciously smooth, creamy, and indulgent shakes made to enjoy any time. With a perfect balance of energizing plant...

    View full details
    $37.27
    $37.27 - $37.27
    $37.27
    $29.30
    $29.30 - $29.30
    $29.30
    Sold out

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare