Skip to content
🎆 RING IN THE NEW YEAR DELICIOUSLY! 🥂 Christmas shipping has passed, but there's still time to stock up for your New Year's celebrations. 📦 See our Shipping Policy for current delivery timelines. 👉 CLICK HERE TO READ IT 👈
🎆 RING IN THE NEW YEAR DELICIOUSLY! 🥂 Christmas shipping has passed, but there's still time to stock up for your New Year's celebrations. 📦 See our Shipping Policy for current delivery timelines. 👉 CLICK HERE TO READ IT 👈

Premium Butter Collection - Pure, Creamy Delights

  • Original price $89.34 - Original price $89.34
    Original price $89.34
    $90.64
    $90.64 - $90.64
    Current price $90.64

    Nuts And More Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Spread, 15 Oz Jar, Pack of 6

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    The Nuts And More Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Spread is the perfect way to add a little sweetness and a lot of flavor to your favorite foods. T...

    View full details
    Original price $89.34 - Original price $89.34
    Original price $89.34
    $90.64
    $90.64 - $90.64
    Current price $90.64
    Sold out
  • Original price $74.34 - Original price $74.34
    Original price $74.34
    $83.61
    $83.61 - $83.61
    Current price $83.61

    Stamey's Bread & Butter Pickles - Case of 6 - 32 oz Jars

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Stamey's Down Home Goodness: Bread & Butter Pickles A Taste of Southern Comfort in Every Jar Indulge in the beloved tangy-sweet flavor of au...

    View full details
    Original price $74.34 - Original price $74.34
    Original price $74.34
    $83.61
    $83.61 - $83.61
    Current price $83.61
    Sold out
  • Original price $27.48 - Original price $27.48
    Original price $27.48
    $38.64
    $38.64 - $38.64
    Current price $38.64

    Nugo Nutrition Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Bar - 1.76 Oz - Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in Decadent Delight: Nugo Nutrition Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Bar A Symphony of Taste and Health Packed with 10 grams of...

    View full details
    Original price $27.48 - Original price $27.48
    Original price $27.48
    $38.64
    $38.64 - $38.64
    Current price $38.64
  • Original price $56.94 - Original price $56.94
    Original price $56.94
    $67.59
    $67.59 - $67.59
    Current price $67.59

    Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roast Crunchy Peanut Butter, 16 oz (Pack of 6)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in the rich, robust flavor of Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roast Crunchy Peanut Butter! Crafted with care in the USA using 95%+ certified organi...

    View full details
    Original price $56.94 - Original price $56.94
    Original price $56.94
    $67.59
    $67.59 - $67.59
    Current price $67.59
    Sold out
  • Original price $15.05 - Original price $15.05
    Original price $15.05
    $18.79
    $18.79 - $18.79
    Current price $18.79

    Spinster Sisters Oatmeal, Milk & Honey Body Butter Bar - 3 Oz.

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Oatmeal, Milk & Honey Body Butter Bar Experience the luxurious nourishment and captivating scent of Spinster Sisters' Oatmeal, Milk & H...

    View full details
    Original price $15.05 - Original price $15.05
    Original price $15.05
    $18.79
    $18.79 - $18.79
    Current price $18.79
    Sold out
  • Original price $87.54 - Original price $87.54
    Original price $87.54
    $88.84
    $88.84 - $88.84
    Current price $88.84

    RXBAR Protein Bar, Peanut Butter Chocolate, 1.83oz, Pack of 6

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Feed Your Cravings, Not Your Guilt: RXBAR Protein Bar, Peanut Butter Chocolate Indulge in Wholesome Goodness Quench Your Hunger with Real Food In...

    View full details
    Original price $87.54 - Original price $87.54
    Original price $87.54
    $88.84
    $88.84 - $88.84
    Current price $88.84
  • Original price $49.08 - Original price $49.08
    Original price $49.08
    $56.47
    $56.47 - $56.47
    Current price $56.47

    Theo Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Double Chocolate - 1.3 Oz, Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Theo Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Double Chocolate - 1.3 Oz Indulge in the delectable delight of Theo Chocolate's Peanut Butter Cup Double Chocola...

    View full details
    Original price $49.08 - Original price $49.08
    Original price $49.08
    $56.47
    $56.47 - $56.47
    Current price $56.47
    Sold out
  • Original price $54.50 - Original price $54.50
    Original price $54.50
    $61.97
    $61.97 - $61.97
    Current price $61.97

    Awake Chocolate Bites, Peanut Butter Chocolate, 50 Pack - 0.58 Oz Each

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the perfect balance of creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate with Awake Chocolate Bites, Peanut Butter Chocolate. Crafted with the fin...

    View full details
    Original price $54.50 - Original price $54.50
    Original price $54.50
    $61.97
    $61.97 - $61.97
    Current price $61.97
  • Original price $78.54 - Original price $78.54
    Original price $78.54
    $81.99
    $81.99 - $81.99
    Current price $81.99

    Fix & Fogg Creamy Cashew Butter, Pack of 6 - 10 Oz Jars

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the Rich, Creamy Goodness of Fix & Fogg Creamy Cashew Butter Fix & Fogg Creamy Cashew Butter Key Features & Benefits: 10...

    View full details
    Original price $78.54 - Original price $78.54
    Original price $78.54
    $81.99
    $81.99 - $81.99
    Current price $81.99
  • Original price $38.28 - Original price $38.28
    Original price $38.28
    $47.67
    $47.67 - $47.67
    Current price $47.67

    Byte Bars: 12-Count Peanut Butter Energy Bars, 1.62oz Each

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Byte Bars: The Best In Energy Snacks A revolutionary new energy bar has been released by Byte Bars. A nutritious and practical snack is available...

    View full details
    Original price $38.28 - Original price $38.28
    Original price $38.28
    $47.67
    $47.67 - $47.67
    Current price $47.67
    Sold out
  • Original price $83.34 - Original price $83.34
    Original price $83.34
    $85.51
    $85.51 - $85.51
    Current price $85.51

    Nuts And More - Peanut Butter Spread Chocolate Maple Pretzels - 15 Oz Case of 6 - Buy Now"

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Discover Nuts and More, a peanut butter spread chocolate maple pretzels case of 6 15-ounce packages! This product features: Country of origin: ...

    View full details
    Original price $83.34 - Original price $83.34
    Original price $83.34
    $85.51
    $85.51 - $85.51
    Current price $85.51
    Sold out
  • Original price $49.08 - Original price $49.08
    Original price $49.08
    $56.67
    $56.67 - $56.67
    Current price $56.67

    Gomacro Macrobar: Organic Sunflower Butter & Chocolate, 2.3 Oz Bars (Case of 12)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Unleash a Burst of Organic Energy with Gomacro Macrobar Sunflower Butter & Chocolate Indulge in Nature's Goodness for Sustained Energy Power ...

    View full details
    Original price $49.08 - Original price $49.08
    Original price $49.08
    $56.67
    $56.67 - $56.67
    Current price $56.67
  • Original price $15.99 - Original price $15.99
    Original price $15.99
    $19.46
    $19.46 - $19.46
    Current price $19.46

    Spinster Sisters Body Butter Bar in Relaxing Lavender Scent, 3 oz

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Soothing Relief, Soft Touch: Spinster Sisters Body Butter Bar is a gentle touch that nourishes your skin with a delectable lavender scent. Experie...

    View full details
    Original price $15.99 - Original price $15.99
    Original price $15.99
    $19.46
    $19.46 - $19.46
    Current price $19.46
    Sold out
  • Original price $26.90 - Original price $26.90
    Original price $26.90
    $40.46
    $40.46 - $40.46
    Current price $40.46

    Chocolove Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate - 1.2 oz - Pack of 10

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in Velvety Delight: Chocolove Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate Crave the perfect harmony of rich, decadent dark chocolate and velvety peanut bu...

    View full details
    Original price $26.90 - Original price $26.90
    Original price $26.90
    $40.46
    $40.46 - $40.46
    Current price $40.46
  • Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $42.96
    $42.96 - $42.96
    Current price $42.96

    Kind Bar Peanut Butter - 12 Pack of 1.4oz Bars

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Nutrient-Rich Energy: Discover Kind Peanut Butter Protein Bars Fuel Your Body with Wholesome Goodness Made with qual...

    View full details
    Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $42.96
    $42.96 - $42.96
    Current price $42.96
    Sold out
  • Original price $71.34 - Original price $71.34
    Original price $71.34
    $75.94
    $75.94 - $75.94
    Current price $75.94

    Pb2 Peanut Butter Powder with Cocoa - 6 x 16 oz

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Proudly enjoy these ideal ways of including authentic deep in flavor peanuts into your favorite foods without additives, oils, or added sugars. Ou...

    View full details
    Original price $71.34 - Original price $71.34
    Original price $71.34
    $75.94
    $75.94 - $75.94
    Current price $75.94
  • Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.69
    $50.69 - $50.69
    Current price $50.69

    Cando Butter Salt Candy Bar, 1.8 Oz, Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in the tantalizing blend of sweet and salty flavors. Perfect for on-the-go snacks, lunchtime cravings, or any time you want a sweet tr...

    View full details
    Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.69
    $50.69 - $50.69
    Current price $50.69
    Sold out
  • Original price $129.61
    Original price $129.61 - Original price $129.61
    Original price $129.61
    Current price $127.10
    $127.10 - $127.10
    Current price $127.10

    Clif Bar Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter - Case of 9 - 2.4 Oz (Pack of 6)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Explore the Harmony of Crunchy Peanut Butter with Clif Bar's Organic Indulgence Wholesome Goodness in Every Bite Certified Organic: Rel...

    View full details
    Original price $129.61
    Original price $129.61 - Original price $129.61
    Original price $129.61
    Current price $127.10
    $127.10 - $127.10
    Current price $127.10
    Sold out
  • Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.69
    $50.69 - $50.69
    Current price $50.69

    Cando Bar - Creamy Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chunks - 1.59 Oz - Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Cando Bars: Satisfy Your Cravings with Creamy Peanut Butter and Rich Chocolate Cando Bar - Creamy Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chunks Indulge in t...

    View full details
    Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.69
    $50.69 - $50.69
    Current price $50.69
    Sold out
  • Original price $82.68 - Original price $82.68
    Original price $82.68
    $84.56
    $84.56 - $84.56
    Current price $84.56

    Lily's 55% Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar, 2.8 Oz, Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Lily's 55% Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar Indulge in guilt-free sweetness Savor the Perfect Ba...

    View full details
    Original price $82.68 - Original price $82.68
    Original price $82.68
    $84.56
    $84.56 - $84.56
    Current price $84.56
  • Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $43.49
    $43.49 - $43.49
    Current price $43.49

    Lily's Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, 1.25 Oz, Pack of 2 (Case of 12)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in the Sweetness of Lily's Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups (Case of 12) Discover an irresistible treat that combines...

    View full details
    Original price $33.48 - Original price $33.48
    Original price $33.48
    $43.49
    $43.49 - $43.49
    Current price $43.49
    Sold out
  • Original price $67.50 - Original price $67.50
    Original price $67.50
    $71.99
    $71.99 - $71.99
    Current price $71.99

    Chocolove XOXO Creamy Peanut Butter in Delicious Milk Chocolate Cups, .6 oz (Case of 50)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge Your Senses with Chocolove XOXO Creamy Peanut Butter Chocolate Cups Satisfy your sweet tooth with the irresistible combination of crea...

    View full details
    Original price $67.50 - Original price $67.50
    Original price $67.50
    $71.99
    $71.99 - $71.99
    Current price $71.99
    Sold out
  • Original price $77.34 - Original price $77.34
    Original price $77.34
    $80.94
    $80.94 - $80.94
    Current price $80.94

    Revival Almond Butter with Vanilla Sea Salt - 10 oz, Pack of 6

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Revival Almond Butter with Vanilla Sea Salt is the perfect choice for a wholesome, indulgent spread that will elevate your breakfast, snacks, and d...

    View full details
    Original price $77.34 - Original price $77.34
    Original price $77.34
    $80.94
    $80.94 - $80.94
    Current price $80.94
    Sold out
  • Original price $89.34 - Original price $89.34
    Original price $89.34
    $90.64
    $90.64 - $90.64
    Current price $90.64

    Nuts And More Peanut Butter Spread Toffee Crunch, 15 Ounce Pack of 6

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Peanut Butter Spread Toffee Crunch Nuts And More Key Features & Benefits: Creamy and irresistible peanut...

    View full details
    Original price $89.34 - Original price $89.34
    Original price $89.34
    $90.64
    $90.64 - $90.64
    Current price $90.64
    Sold out