Skip to content
🎄 HOLIDAY SHIPPING REMINDER — SHOP EARLY! 🎁 The season’s heating up! Order early to get your gourmet goods on time. 📦 Check our Shipping Policy for shipping speeds and deadlines. 👉 CLICK HERE TO READ IT 👈
🎄 HOLIDAY SHIPPING REMINDER — SHOP EARLY! 🎁 The season’s heating up! Order early to get your gourmet goods on time. 📦 Check our Shipping Policy for shipping speeds and deadlines. 👉 CLICK HERE TO READ IT 👈

Peanut Pantry - Crunchy Delights for Every Occasion

  • Original price $77.90 - Original price $77.90
    Original price $77.90
    $80.26
    $80.26 - $80.26
    Current price $80.26

    Skinnydipped Peanut Butter Cup Dark Chocolate, 3.17 Oz - Pack of 10

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Skinnydipped Peanut Butter Cup Dark Chocolate Indulge in Ultimate Decadence Satisfy your sweet cravings with Skinnydipped Peanut Butter Cup Dark ...

    View full details
    Original price $77.90 - Original price $77.90
    Original price $77.90
    $80.26
    $80.26 - $80.26
    Current price $80.26
  • Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01

    Peanut Butter & Co. White Chocolate Wonderful Peanut Butter (6-Pack, 1 lb.)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Indulge in the Irresistible Delight of Peanut Butter & Co.'s White Chocolate Wonderful Peanut Butter A Sweet and Savory Harmony Prepare your ...

    View full details
    Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01
  • Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01

    Peanut Butter & Co. The Bee's Knees, 16 oz., Case of 6

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Creamy, Dreamy Peanut Butter with a Hint of Honey Indulge in the velvety embrace of Peanut Butter & Co.'s The Bee's Knees, where the rich, nut...

    View full details
    Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01
  • Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01

    Peanut Butter & Co. Mighty Maple Peanut Butter (Pack of 6) - 16 Oz.

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Sweet Dreams are Made of Peanut Butter A Maple-icious Twist on a Classic Crafted with real maple syrup for a touch of sweetness and a burst o...

    View full details
    Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01
  • Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01

    Peanut Butter & Co. Cinnamon Swirl Peanut Butter - 16 Oz. Jars, Pack of 6

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Swirl in Sensational Flavor with Peanut Butter & Co. Cinnamon Swirl Peanut Butter Cinnamon and Peanut Butter Harmony Indulge in a delightful ...

    View full details
    Original price $43.74 - Original price $43.74
    Original price $43.74
    $53.01
    $53.01 - $53.01
    Current price $53.01
  • Original price $46.74 - Original price $46.74
    Original price $46.74
    $55.01
    $55.01 - $55.01
    Current price $55.01

    Pb2 Peanut Butter Powder - Convenient 6.5 Oz Container (Case of 6)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Kickstart your health journey with Pb2, the all-natural peanut butter powder that packs a punch of nutrition. This convenient 6.5oz container is p...

    View full details
    Original price $46.74 - Original price $46.74
    Original price $46.74
    $55.01
    $55.01 - $55.01
    Current price $55.01
  • Original price $47.74
    Original price $47.74 - Original price $47.74
    Original price $47.74
    Current price $37.80
    $37.80 - $37.80
    Current price $37.80

    Pb2 - Peanut Powder Pre+Probiotic (Pack of 6-6.5oz)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Pb2 peanut powder pre+probiotic provides an all-natural source of plant-based proteins with a tasty boost of probiotics. Each 6.5oz pack of 6 is ...

    View full details
    Original price $47.74
    Original price $47.74 - Original price $47.74
    Original price $47.74
    Current price $37.80
    $37.80 - $37.80
    Current price $37.80
    Sold out
  • Original price $49.60 - Original price $49.60
    Original price $49.60
    $53.18
    $53.18 - $53.18
    Current price $53.18

    Organic Macrobar - Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip (Pack of 12) 2.5 Oz Bars

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    GoMacro MacroBar Vegan Bar, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip is the perfect snack for those looking for a delicious and nutritious treat. This pack o...

    View full details
    Original price $49.60 - Original price $49.60
    Original price $49.60
    $53.18
    $53.18 - $53.18
    Current price $53.18
    Sold out
  • Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $51.59
    $51.59 - $51.59
    Current price $51.59

    ONE Bar Protein Peanut Butter Cup - 60g Bar

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    ONE Bar Protein Peanut Butter Cup Indulge in the irresistible taste of ONE Bar Protein Peanut Butter Cup, a 60g bar crafted to satisfy your cr...

    View full details
    Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $51.59
    $51.59 - $51.59
    Current price $51.59
  • Original price $44.79 - Original price $44.79
    Original price $44.79
    $53.90
    $53.90 - $53.90
    Current price $53.90

    Once Again Creamy No Salt Peanut Butter (5 lbs)

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Once Again Organic Creamy No Salt Peanut Butter, 5 lbs - Nut Butters - Gluten Free Pantry - Grocery Once Again Creamy No Salt Peanut Butter Cre...

    View full details
    Original price $44.79 - Original price $44.79
    Original price $44.79
    $53.90
    $53.90 - $53.90
    Current price $53.90
  • Original price $32.28 - Original price $32.28
    Original price $32.28
    $42.20
    $42.20 - $42.20
    Current price $42.20

    Ocho Candy Peanut Butter Candy Bar - 1.5 Oz, Pack of 12

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Ocho Candy Peanut Butter Candy Bar, 1.5 Oz, Pack of 12 A Classic Treat for Peanut Butter Lovers Indulge in the timeless goodness of Ocho Candy Pea...

    View full details
    Original price $32.28 - Original price $32.28
    Original price $32.28
    $42.20
    $42.20 - $42.20
    Current price $42.20
    Sold out
  • Original price $40.68 - Original price $40.68
    Original price $40.68
    $49.36
    $49.36 - $49.36
    Current price $49.36

    Lily's Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, 12 Pack - 1.25 oz each

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Lily's Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, 12 Pack Indulge in the delectable flavors of Lily's Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, masterfully craft...

    View full details
    Original price $40.68 - Original price $40.68
    Original price $40.68
    $49.36
    $49.36 - $49.36
    Current price $49.36
  • Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28 - Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28
    Current price $54.77
    $54.77 - $54.77
    Current price $54.77

    Lily's Dark Chocolate 55% Cacao with Peanut Butter 2.8oz Bar (Pack of 12)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in Pure Decadence with Lily's Dark Chocolate and Creamy Peanut Butter Bars Lily's Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups: A Symphony of Sweet a...

    View full details
    Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28 - Original price $69.28
    Original price $69.28
    Current price $54.77
    $54.77 - $54.77
    Current price $54.77
    Sold out
  • Original price $29.88 - Original price $29.88
    Original price $29.88
    $39.89
    $39.89 - $39.89
    Current price $39.89

    Munk Pack Keto Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Unleash Your Keto Cravings with Munk Pack Keto Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate The Perfect Keto Snack, Minus the Guilt Indulge in the irresist...

    View full details
    Original price $29.88 - Original price $29.88
    Original price $29.88
    $39.89
    $39.89 - $39.89
    Current price $39.89
  • Original price $63.92 - Original price $63.92
    Original price $63.92
    $69.29
    $69.29 - $69.29
    Current price $69.29

    Maxine's Heavenly Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Cookies, 8 Pack of 7.2 Oz. Packages

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Heavenly Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Bliss, One Bite at a Time Key Features and Benefits: Indulge in generously sized 7.2 Oz. packages...

    View full details
    Original price $63.92 - Original price $63.92
    Original price $63.92
    $69.29
    $69.29 - $69.29
    Current price $69.29
    Sold out
  • Original price $48.72 - Original price $48.72
    Original price $48.72
    $56.34
    $56.34 - $56.34
    Current price $56.34

    Kind - Simple Crunch Peanut Butter (Pack of 8-5/1.4 Oz)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    This pack of 8-5/1.4 Oz of Kind - Simple Crunch Peanut Butter is a delicious, crunchy, and nutritious snack perfect for any occasion. Crafted in ...

    View full details
    Original price $48.72 - Original price $48.72
    Original price $48.72
    $56.34
    $56.34 - $56.34
    Current price $56.34
    Sold out
  • Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $51.71
    $51.71 - $51.71
    Current price $51.71

    Lupii Bites Protein Peanut Butter with Cacao Nibs, 12-Pack of 1.76 Oz Each

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Lupii Bites Protein Peanut Butter with Cacao Nibs, 12-Pack of 1.76 Oz Each Unleash Your Cravings with Lupii Bites: The Ultimate Protein-Powered P...

    View full details
    Original price $43.08 - Original price $43.08
    Original price $43.08
    $51.71
    $51.71 - $51.71
    Current price $51.71
    Sold out
  • Original price $64.72 - Original price $64.72
    Original price $64.72
    $70.53
    $70.53 - $70.53
    Current price $70.53

    Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter Spread - Crunchy, Peanut Butter Alternative (8 Pack)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Crunchy Cookie Butter Spread | 8-Pack of 13-ounce Jars Cookie Butter Alternative to Peanut Butter Key Features & Benefits: Creamy, crunchy ...

    View full details
    Original price $64.72 - Original price $64.72
    Original price $64.72
    $70.53
    $70.53 - $70.53
    Current price $70.53
    Sold out
  • Original price $126.88
    Original price $126.88 - Original price $126.88
    Original price $126.88
    Current price $120.06
    $120.06 - $120.06
    Current price $120.06

    Lily's Sweets Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate, 3.2 Oz - Case of 12

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Feel the sweet and savory joy with Lily's Sweets Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate The Perfect Indulgence for Peanut Butter Lovers Crav...

    View full details
    Original price $126.88
    Original price $126.88 - Original price $126.88
    Original price $126.88
    Current price $120.06
    $120.06 - $120.06
    Current price $120.06
  • Original price $47.94 - Original price $47.94
    Original price $47.94
    $59.73
    $59.73 - $59.73
    Current price $59.73

    Jars Once Again Creamy Unsweetened Peanut Butter (6-Pack, 16 oz Jars)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in the Creamy Goodness of Jars Once Again Unsweetened Peanut Butter Craving a Healthy, Wholesome Treat? Introducing Jars Once Again's Uns...

    View full details
    Original price $47.94 - Original price $47.94
    Original price $47.94
    $59.73
    $59.73 - $59.73
    Current price $59.73
    Sold out
  • Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50 - Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50
    Current price $23.74
    $23.74 - $23.74
    Current price $23.74

    Kize Concepts - Energy Bar Raw Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip (Pack of 10 1.5oz)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    This Kize peanut butter chocolate chip raw energy bar provides 9 g. of protein and is made from only six delicious ingredients: premium peanut bu...

    View full details
    Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50 - Original price $30.50
    Original price $30.50
    Current price $23.74
    $23.74 - $23.74
    Current price $23.74
    Sold out
  • Original price $44.64 - Original price $44.64
    Original price $44.64
    $52.13
    $52.13 - $52.13
    Current price $52.13

    Larabar Peanut Butter Cookie Mega Pack - 16 pack - 1.7 Oz.

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Larabar Peanut Butter Cookie Mega Pack - 16 pack - 1.7 Oz. Delightful Snack: Larabar Peanut Butter Cookie Mega Pack Key Features and Benefits...

    View full details
    Original price $44.64 - Original price $44.64
    Original price $44.64
    $52.13
    $52.13 - $52.13
    Current price $52.13
  • Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.53
    $50.53 - $50.53
    Current price $50.53

    Kate's Real Food - Peanut Butter Hemp Protein Fruit & Nut Bars - Case Of 12 - 2.2 Oz

    Cozy Farm
    In stock

    Elevate Your Snacking Experience with Kate's Real Food Peanut Butter Hemp Protein Fruit & Nut Bars Indulge in the irresistible taste and whole...

    View full details
    Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price $41.88
    $50.53
    $50.53 - $50.53
    Current price $50.53
  • Original price $138.88
    Original price $138.88 - Original price $138.88
    Original price $138.88
    Current price $113.24
    $113.24 - $113.24
    Current price $113.24

    Lake Champlain Chocolates - Chocolate Peanut Butter Jubilee Bar (5 oz, Pack of 12)

    Cozy Farm
    Out of stock

    Indulge in the delectable taste of Lake Champlain Chocolates Chocolate Peanut Butter Jubilee Bar. Bursting with a harmonious blend of velvety smoo...

    View full details
    Original price $138.88
    Original price $138.88 - Original price $138.88
    Original price $138.88
    Current price $113.24
    $113.24 - $113.24
    Current price $113.24
    Sold out