The Feast of the Seven Fishes is the Italian-American Christmas Eve meal: a long, multi-course dinner built entirely on fish and seafood, eaten the night of December 24. The fish is the easy part, because it comes from the fish market the day before. The pantry underneath it is what decides whether the night goes smoothly: good olive oil for frying and finishing, clam broth for the linguine and the stew, tomatoes and paste for the baccalà, pasta, flour for the dredge, and a few quiet staples like breadcrumbs and raisins. This guide covers what the feast is, how the seven courses are usually built, and exactly what to stock two weeks ahead so December 24 is cooking, not shopping.
In Italy the night is called La Vigilia, the Vigil, and the meal grows out of the Roman Catholic practice of abstaining from meat on the eve of a holy day. No meat and no animal fat meant fish, very often fried in olive oil, and a long table of it. The tradition is Southern Italian at its roots. Calabria in particular has a documented history of a Christmas Eve meal of seven or thirteen fish dishes, and the families who carried it to the United States came largely during the great wave of immigration between 1880 and 1930, settling in the Northeast and the industrial Midwest. Boston's North End, the South Shore, Providence and the Connecticut shoreline all still set this table.
The number is the part everyone argues about. Seven is tied by different families to the seven sacraments, the seven hills of Rome, or simply to the number being lucky, and there is no agreement on which story is right. Plenty of households serve nine, eleven or thirteen courses, and some do not count at all. The name "Feast of the Seven Fishes" is itself an American invention: the oldest newspaper reference anyone has found dates to 1983, decades after the meal was already a fixture in Italian-American kitchens. So if your grandmother said nine, your grandmother was right.
Menus differ by region and by family, but the structure below is the one most New England tables recognize. The right-hand column is the point of this article: the shelf-stable ingredients each course depends on, all of which can be in the house weeks before the fish arrives.
| Course | Typical dish | The pantry under it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Antipasto: marinated anchovies, olives, insalata di mare (octopus and shrimp salad) | Extra virgin olive oil, lemon, parsley, good vinegar |
| 2 | Fried smelts, or fried calamari | Olive oil for the fry, semolina or 00 flour for the dredge, breadcrumbs |
| 3 | Baccalà salad, or baccalà alla napoletana (salt cod with tomato, olives and raisins) | Tomato purée or paste, golden raisins, olive oil |
| 4 | Linguine with clams | Dry pasta, clam broth, olive oil, garlic, chili |
| 5 | Shrimp scampi, or shrimp fra diavolo | Olive oil, tomato, chili flake |
| 6 | Stuffed calamari, or mussels in red sauce | Breadcrumbs, tomato purée, olive oil |
| 7 | Cioppino or zuppa di pesce, the stew that uses everything left | Clam broth, diced tomatoes, tomato paste, olive oil |
Look down that right-hand column and the same five things repeat: olive oil, clam broth, tomatoes, pasta and flour. That is the order to place in November.
Seven courses means olive oil is doing three jobs at once: shallow-frying the smelts and calamari, building the base of every sauce, and finishing the salads and the stew at the table. Most families run out halfway through the fry. A 3 liter tin of Aria Extra Virgin Olive Oil is the right size for a home table of twelve, and restaurants and caterers running the feast as a prix fixe move to the 2 x 10 liter case, where the fry station and the sauce station each get their own container. Keep a small bottle of your best oil aside for the finish and let the tin do the work.
Linguine with clams and the closing stew both start with clam broth, and so does any cioppino worth the name. Fresh clams give up a cup or so of liquor; a case of Clam Juice in 46 oz cans gives you the quart you actually need for a pot of linguine for a crowd, plus the base for the zuppa di pesce. It is the single most forgotten item on the Christmas Eve shopping list and the one that cannot be improvised at 6 pm on December 24.
Baccalà alla napoletana, shrimp fra diavolo, mussels in red sauce and the stew all want tomato, and they do not all want the same tomato. Tomato paste builds the backbone of the fra diavolo and deepens the stew. Tomato purée is the smooth red sauce for the baccalà and the mussels. Diced tomatoes give the cioppino its texture. A #10 can of each covers a long table with sauce to spare for the week after.
The linguine course is the one everyone waits for, and it is only as good as the pasta. De Cecco bronze-die pasta holds the clam sauce the way a smooth extruded pasta cannot; we wrote a full piece on why De Cecco is the standard if you want the detail. For the fry, a dredge of semolina gives smelts and calamari the sandy, crisp crust the old North End kitchens are known for; Caputo 00 gives a finer, lighter coat if that is your family's style. If you make fresh pasta for the night, the same two bags cover it.
Stuffed calamari and baked clams run on breadcrumbs; panko gives a lighter, crunchier stuffing than fine crumbs and takes garlic and parsley well. Baccalà alla napoletana is not right without golden raisins against the salt and the tomato. Round out the list with garlic, parsley, lemons, chili flake, capers and olives from your regular shop, and the pantry is complete.
Two weeks out (around December 10): Place the pantry order: olive oil, clam broth, tomatoes, pasta, flour, breadcrumbs, raisins. Everything on this list is shelf stable and ships nationwide, so there is no reason to carry it home from a crowded store the week of Christmas.
One week out: Confirm the fish order with your fish market, and buy the baccalà now. Salt cod needs two to three days of soaking in cold water, changed morning and night, before it is ready to cook, so it comes home earlier than the fresh fish.
December 21 or 22: Start soaking the baccalà. Make the tomato sauce base and refrigerate it; it improves overnight.
December 23: Pick up the fresh fish, clams, mussels, shrimp and squid. Clean the calamari and make the stuffing. Make the seafood salad; it is better after a night in the dressing.
December 24: Fry first, while the oil is clean and the family is still arriving. Linguine goes last before the stew, because it waits for no one.
Italian restaurants across New England book December 24 as a seven-course prix fixe, and the economics are simple: the fish is bought in the last 48 hours at market price, while everything under it is bought in November at case price. Olive oil by the 10 liter, clam broth by the case, tomatoes by the #10 and pasta by the 20 lb case belong on an early December truck, before holiday routes fill and before the fish invoice arrives. If you buy for a kitchen, request a quote on the full pantry and we will put it together as one order.
There is no fixed list, but the most common are baccalà (salt cod), calamari, smelts, anchovies, clams, shrimp and mussels, with octopus, eel and lobster appearing on many tables. Most families repeat a fish across courses, so seven dishes does not always mean seven species.
No. Seven is the most common number in the United States, but nine, eleven and thirteen are all traditional, and some families simply cook as much fish as the table can hold. The name is American; the custom is older and looser than the name.
Olive oil, canned tomatoes, clam broth, dry pasta, flour, breadcrumbs and raisins all keep for months in a cool cupboard. Two weeks ahead is comfortable; a month ahead is fine. Only the fish and the fresh produce need to wait for the last few days.
Plan on two to three days in cold water in the refrigerator, changing the water twice a day. Thicker center cuts need the full three days. Taste a corner before cooking; it should be seasoned, not salty.
Both are tomato-and-broth seafood stews that use whatever is left from the other courses. Cioppino is the San Francisco Italian-American version, usually with Dungeness crab and a wine-heavy broth; zuppa di pesce is the Southern Italian original. On Christmas Eve in New England the names are used interchangeably and the pot is the same: clam broth, tomato, olive oil, garlic, and every shell on the counter.
Yes. Every pantry item in this guide is shelf stable and ships anywhere in the United States from Specialty Food Source. Order by the second week of December for comfortable delivery before Christmas Eve.
{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}
